On the relationship between K concentration, grain size and dose in feldspar

TY - JOUR

T1 - On the relationship between K concentration, grain size and dose in feldspar

AU - Buylaert, J. P.

AU - Újvári, G.

AU - Murray, A. S.

AU - Smedley, R. K.

AU - Kook, M.

PY - 2018/12/15

Y1 - 2018/12/15

N2 - Previous work has been unable to establish a relationship between K concentration and De in single-grains of feldspar. Here we use four well-bleached sediments with low external dose rate (typically ≤1.5 Gy ka−1) to investigate this relationship. Single and multi-grain pIRIR measurements and μ-XRF analyses are made on Na- and K-rich extracts; μ-XRF is directly applied to grains sitting in single-grain discs to minimise uncertainty in grain identification. Micro-XRF is shown to be sufficiently precise and accurate and luminescence instrument reproducibility is confirmed using dose recovery measurements on heated feldspar. We are again unable to establish any correlation between single-grain De and K concentration, even in feldspar grains for which the internal dose rate should dominate. We also measure highly variable Rb concentrations in these grains and are unable to detect, at the single-grain level, the correlation between K and Rb previously observed in multi-grain investigations. Nevertheless, these results are unable to explain the lack of De correlation with K. Finally, we investigate the dependence of De on grain size (isochrons). Linear correlations are observed but slopes are inconsistent with model prediction. We conclude that this surprising absence of the expected relationships between dose and K concentration and grain size does not arise from analytical precision, incomplete bleaching, sediment mixing or fading. It appears that we cannot measure feldspar doses in these samples as accurately as we thought.

AB - Previous work has been unable to establish a relationship between K concentration and De in single-grains of feldspar. Here we use four well-bleached sediments with low external dose rate (typically ≤1.5 Gy ka−1) to investigate this relationship. Single and multi-grain pIRIR measurements and μ-XRF analyses are made on Na- and K-rich extracts; μ-XRF is directly applied to grains sitting in single-grain discs to minimise uncertainty in grain identification. Micro-XRF is shown to be sufficiently precise and accurate and luminescence instrument reproducibility is confirmed using dose recovery measurements on heated feldspar. We are again unable to establish any correlation between single-grain De and K concentration, even in feldspar grains for which the internal dose rate should dominate. We also measure highly variable Rb concentrations in these grains and are unable to detect, at the single-grain level, the correlation between K and Rb previously observed in multi-grain investigations. Nevertheless, these results are unable to explain the lack of De correlation with K. Finally, we investigate the dependence of De on grain size (isochrons). Linear correlations are observed but slopes are inconsistent with model prediction. We conclude that this surprising absence of the expected relationships between dose and K concentration and grain size does not arise from analytical precision, incomplete bleaching, sediment mixing or fading. It appears that we cannot measure feldspar doses in these samples as accurately as we thought.

KW - Dose

KW - Feldspar

KW - Isochron

KW - Potassium

KW - Rubidium

U2 - 10.1016/j.radmeas.2018.06.003

DO - 10.1016/j.radmeas.2018.06.003

M3 - Journal article

AN - SCOPUS:85048560420

SN - 1350-4487

VL - 120

SP - 181

EP - 187

JO - Radiation Measurements

JF - Radiation Measurements

ER -