Department of Management

The Coordination of Independently-Owned Vacuum Tube Patents in the Early Radio Alleged Patent “Thicket”

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperResearchpeer-review

  • John Howells
  • Katznelson Ron D, President of Bi-Level Technologies, Encinitas, California, USA., United States
It has been proposed that difficulties in negotiating cross-licenses under multiple, independently-owned and ”overlapping” patents may lead entrepreneurs to hold-up or deter development of technology covered by such patents. The literature alleges these features were present in radio development during 1905-1920, with numerous allegations of an impasse in bargaining the necessary patent rights for development. This paper seeks to determine with new precision how entrepreneurs and managers actually managed patent rights in this scenario. Accordingly, we re-examine the legal trajectories and entrepreneurial exploitation of patents on early vacuum tube technology where Fleming’s diode patent was alleged to have ”overlapped” with De Forest’s triode patents. We show, by means of the relevant historical record, patent claims, litigation records and other relevant law, how patent rights were resolved by the courts and by the immunity of suppliers to the Government from patent infringement liability. We trace the cross-licensing agreements between the different radio interests and find that licensing was always chosen over hold-up and so enabled robust, state-of-the-art radio development.
Original languageEnglish
Publication year18 Sep 2014
Number of pages20
Publication statusPublished - 18 Sep 2014
EventSymposium on History of Patented Innovation - George Mason University School of Law, Arlington, Virginia, USA, United States
Duration: 18 Sep 201419 Sep 2014


ConferenceSymposium on History of Patented Innovation
LocationGeorge Mason University School of Law
CountryUnited States
CityArlington, Virginia, USA

See relations at Aarhus University Citationformats

ID: 76753905